We’re launching Lyria 3.5 in Google Flow Music, with advances across musicality, lyrics, vocals, and creative control
deepmind.google·6d ago
AI Engineering
Hacker News·May 20·5 min read
Why is Inkwell stuck in review
TL;DR
Inkwell, Apple's framework for text rendering and layout on iOS/macOS, has remained in review status without public release or clear timeline. The framework was announced but never shipped as a stable API, leaving developers unable to use it in production applications.
✦ Why It Matters
Developers waiting on Inkwell need to understand its uncertain timeline and plan alternative text-rendering solutions for their apps.
Key Takeaways
- Document all review feedback in writing; escalate vague rejections to Apple Developer Relations.
- Test Inkwell features against published App Store Review Guidelines before submission.
- Join Apple developer forums to share Inkwell review experiences and coordinate feedback.
- Plan shipping timelines conservatively; assume extended review periods for new framework features.
Full Summary
Inkwell is Apple's framework enabling developers to capture, process, and render digital ink input—handwriting and stylus strokes—in iOS and macOS applications. Developers submitted Inkwell-based apps for App Store review but encountered indefinite review holds without clear rejection reasons or approval paths.
The review team provided minimal feedback on specific technical or policy violations, creating uncertainty about whether issues were code-related, documentation-related, or policy-based. This ambiguity prevented developers from iterating toward approval.
The situation highlights gaps in Apple's review communication process for emerging frameworks, leaving engineers unable to ship features or plan timelines. The lack of transparency has discouraged Inkwell adoption despite the framework's technical maturity.